Our Thinking

Media Portrayals of Women are more Powerful than ‘Bossy’

Facebook COO Sheryl Sandberg, who famously advised women last year to “lean in,” has launched a campaign that’s become ubiquitous in social media. She wants people to stop applying the word “bossy” to little girls because it’s never applied to little boys.


I don’t know whether the “Ban Bossy” campaign, as it is called, will be effective in any way, but I do know that imagery, storytelling and portrayals of women in advertising and the popular culture are probably far more impactful on how society views women and girls.


In the 1970s, “The Mary Tyler Moore” show featured Mary Richards, a career woman over 30, unmarried and perfectly happy. In fact, her marital status had nothing to do with any theme or story line of the show, yet that aspect of the sitcom was considered revolutionary but only in retrospect.


The 1980s gave feminism and female friendships a southern accent in “Designing Women.” By the 1990s, “Murphy Brown” stirred things up when that unmarried career woman, decided to have a baby without having a husband.


Contrast Mary Richards to the quartet of women in “Sex and the City.” Though they were all monied professionals, also in their 30s, their stories had two themes: The pursuit of male partners in marriage or sex, but not necessarily for both.


The second decade of the 21st century brought us Olivia Pope — a strong woman making her way in Washington, D.C.


All of these fictional women captivated our imaginations because their shows were well written and their characters so well defined that they felt like our friends, colleagues, relatives and perhaps even ourselves.


If the term “bossy” was applied to any of them, it probably wasn’t an aspersion. Consider that the title of Tina Fey’s 2011 memoir is Bossypants, the thought being that you’re nobody until someone calls you “bossy.”


Mass-media depictions affect our perceptions even if we’re not aware that it’s happening. Our favorite shows work on us much like advertising in that they create stereotypes or expectations about people’s aspirations and behavior.


In advertising, Dove’s “Real beauty” campaign conveys the disconnect between what the ad industry and other image-makers consider the paradigm of female beauty. The reality is that beauty is more elastic and contextual and can sometimes have nothing to do with physique.


The subtexts of TV shows and movies are less obvious but no less powerful in impact.


My 15-year-old daughter follows “Scandal.” Ten years ago, a “fixer” such as Olivia Pope probably would have been written as “Oliver Pope” and played by a white male. People my daughter’s age don’t even stop to think about that. She recently tweeted that she wanted to be Olivia Pope when she grew up and used the hashtag “gladiator.”


It’s difficult to measure the extent to which these characters influence real-life people except to point out that life often imitates art. How they are depicted has larger implications for the average American woman. Here’s why:


  • These shows and characters influence girls who watch them in terms of self image, acceptability and what’s possible in their lives. Today, more than ever, the line between advertising and entertainment is blurred. A screen is a screen is a screen to many people because of product placement.


  • All these readily accessible pieces of content start to establish stereotypes and beliefs about women’s roles. For years, advertising has been under fire for creating and reinforcing bad stereotypes, while entertainment continues to get a pass in that area.


  • Many female icons have shattered negative stereotypes, but today, the impact of these portrayals is more potent because of the “soap box” provided to everyone via social media. If people identify with a character now, they tweet about her, blog, post to Facebook, vote up on Reddit, Stumble Upon, Pinterest or create a Tumblr about her. The perceptions of perceptions are now disseminated on a scale that was never before possible.


  • In entertainment and advertising, once something is successful, everyone tries to figure out how to replicate it, for better and for worse. If women are portrayed as strong and powerful, and those portrayals get ratings, there’ll be more impetus to create more shows with those types of characters. The converse situation can also happen.


A 2012 university study with excerpted results published in The Atlantic said that both women and men had more positive views of women after viewing fictional content in which women were portrayed as strong, self-determining characters even if they were victims of violence in the story.


Let’s face it. As image-makers working in advertising or entertainment, we have to believe that the content we create has an effect on the audience that consumes it. Otherwise, why would we be in these industries? For our daughters’ sakes, let’s understand that our fictional or aspirational creations have a long-term impact that transcends revenues.


Being called “bossy” is probably the least of our worries.


View article on Advertising Age.


Tags: News, Our Thinking

See All Articles
Agency News
Carmichael Lynch Wins Two Clio Sports Awards
Our Thinking
Forging a Grateful Future
Our Thinking
Media Portrayals of Women are more Powerful than 'Bossy'
Carmichael Lynch Carmichael Cares Sustainability
World of Business Ideas
Say It Simply
Carmichael Lynch Carmichael Cares Sustainability
Huffington Post
A Man, A Turkey: Thanksgiving Unplugged
Carmichael Lynch Carmichael Cares Rooftop
Huffington Post
Excuse Me, I Must Take This
Carmichael Lynch Carmichael Cares Sustainability
Movie Theaters are the Walking Dead
Carmichael Lynch Rooftop Stairs
Huffington Post
Here's to Longer Goodbyes
Carmichael Lynch Carmichael Cares Sustainability
Fast Company
How the Catholic Church should Prepare for the Pope to become the #Pope
Carmichael Lynch Water tower
Advertising Age
Supporting the New Four-Year Career
Carmichael Lynch Wall
Advertising Age
Marketers Can Learn from the Boom in Online College Classes
Carmichael Lynch Carmichael Cares Sustainability
Advertising Age
How Brands Will Carry on the Social Conversation in 2013
Carmichael Lynch Water tower
Huffington Post
A Home Unplugged